Fatty's Fish Shack

Boom Boom Shrimp

20 pcs. Fried shrimp topped with spicy sauce.

Price: 15.00

Fried Clam Strips

1/2 lb. served with tartar sauce.

Price: 13.00

Fried Calamari

Served with tartar sauce.

Price: 15.00

Coconut Shrimp

Served with cocktail sauce and Thai chili sauce.

Price: 15.00

Grouper Nuggets

Served with our tartar sauce.

Price: 18.00

Bahamian Conch Fritters

Served with our special sauce.

Price: 16.00

Gator Bites

Crispy fried gator tail served with spicy dressing.

Price: 16.00

Crab Cake

2ct. Served over lettuce with remoulade or tartar sauce.

Price: 19.00

Fresh Mussels

Seasoned with white wine, shallots, Garlic & parsley; served with French bread.

Price: 17.00

Oysters Rockefeller

Price: 17.00

Smoked Fish Dip

Made with mahi or tuna. Served with Crackers & celery.

Price: 13.00

Octo Soft Pretzel

Soft pretzel served warm with mustard.

Price: 11.50

House Nachos

Chicken or beef with cheese, pico, lettuce, jalapeños & southwest sauce.

Price: 16.00

Tarpon Greek Salad

Lettuce, tomato, cucumber, pepperoncini, beets, peppers, onion, olives, feta and one shrimp over potato salad.

Price: 12.00

Andrea's Beach Salad

Greens, cucumber, sliced strawberries, trail mix, hickory-smoked Feta & Raspberry vinaigrette.

Price: 14.00

Wedge Salad

Iceberg lettuce wedge, tomato, bacon blue cheese dressing & a balsamic glaze.

Price: 11.00

House Caesar Salad

Chopped romaine, shaved parmesan, garlic Croutons & Caesar dressing.

Price: 11.00

Shrimp and Corn Chowder

A southern inspired favorite at fatty's fish shack loaded with corn, potatoes, vegetables, and shrimp. May pack a slight kick with our house Cajun seasoning. Served with saltine crackers.

Price: 8.00

Michael's Famous Greek Chicken Lemon Soup

Price: 8.00

New England Clam Chowder

New England style clam chowder a creamy soup full of clams, vegetables, and made with heavy cream. Served with saltine crackers.

Price: 6.00

Lobster Bisque

Price: 8.00

Tampa Cuban

Ham, salami, roast pork, Swiss cheese, pickles, Mayo & Mustard on pressed Cuban bread.

Price: 14.00

Fish Shack Sandwich

Grilled or fried with lettuce, tomato and tartar sauce.

Price: 17.00

Crab Sandwich

Lightly breaded crabmeat with lettuce, Tomato & Tartar sauce.

Price: 17.00

Chicken Sandwich

Grilled or fried with lettuce, Tomato & onion.

Price: 16.00

Prime Burger

8 oz. all beef patty, lettuce, tomato, onion, and pickle.

Price: 15.00

Filet Tips Quesadilla

Chopped beef tips with pico and cheese in a flour tortilla; served with lettuce, sour cream and jalapeños.

Price: 20.00

Chicken Quesadilla

Grilled chicken with pico and cheese in a flour tortilla. Served with lettuce, sour cream and jalapeños.

Price: 14.00

Shrimp Quesadilla

Grilled or blackened shrimp, pico and cheese in a flour tortilla. Served with lettuce, sour cream and jalapeño.

Price: 16.00

Buffalo Chicken Quesadilla

Buffalo chicken, red onion, blue cheese crumbles & cheese in a flour tortilla; with lettuce, sour Cream & jalapeños.

Price: 15.00

Cuban Quesadilla

Mojo roasted pork, smoked ham, salami, Swiss cheese, dill Pickles & Mustard drizzle.

Price: 14.00

Fatty's Shack Tacos

2 pcs. Choice of protein with pineapple pico, cabbage, Cheese & remoulade.

Price: 15.00

Southwest Tacos

2 pcs. Choice of protein with lettuce, cheese, pico & southwest sauce.

Price: 13.00

Mahi-Mahi

Grilled fillet served with pineapple salsa.

Price: 21.00

Fresh Grouper

Fried or boiled with lemon, garlic, oregano, and diced onion

Price: 25.00

Cajun Redfish

Cajun seasoned blackened fillet served grilled.

Price: 27.00

Key West Shrimp

Half or full pound of pink shrimp boiled in old bay seasoning: peel & eat

Price: 18.00

Filet Tips

8oz filet mignon tips grilled or blackened.

Price: 25.00

Fish & Chips

Pub-style milk battered cod with fries, malt vinegar, tartar Sauce & lemon.

Price: 18.00

Island Hogfish

Broiled or fried in ginger lime butter.

Price: 25.00

Fried Shrimp

Served with cocktail sauce.

Price: 18.00

Fisherman's Platter

Fried shrimp, cod, clams & hush puppies.

Price: 25.00

Mac & Cheese

Price: 14.00

Bread Pudding

Price: 9.00

Vanilla Ice Cream

Price: 2.50

French Fries

Side of French fries served with a side of ketchup.

Price: 4.50

Potato Salad

Price: 4.50

Hush Puppies

Seven of our house hush puppies.

Price: 4.50

Coleslaw

House slaw made in house.

Price: 4.50

Daily Vegetable

Price: 4.50

Black Beans & Rice

Price: 4.50

Mac & Cheese

Parmesan and gruyere blended with heavy cream mixed with house pasta. Sprinkled with a monterey cheddar blend.

Price: 4.50

Coke Products

Price: 3.50

Iced Tea

Price: 3.50

Lemonade

Price: 3.50

Kids Cheese Burger

Served with fries and a drink

Price: 9.00

Kids Hot Dog

Served with fries and a drink

Price: 9.00

Kids Chicken Tenders

Served with fries and a drink

Price: 9.00

Kids Cod Nugget

Served with fries and a drink

Price: 10.00

Kids Mac & Cheese

Served with fries and a drink

Price: 10.00